Many people assume that any dark room and a brooding detective makes for a great watch. You end up wasting hours on slow plots that lead absolutely nowhere.
If you want the best mystery tv shows on amazon prime video, you need a sharp narrative hook. These stories keep you guessing until the very last frame. Stick around for these classic whodunits and clever capers.
Get this delivered free. Try Amazon Prime for 30 days.
Enjoy free Same-Day, One-Day, and Two-Day delivery on millions of items, plus Amazon Prime Video and members-only deals during Amazon Prime Big Deal Days (Oct 6–7).
Start My Free Amazon Prime TrialOnly $14.99/month (plus tax) after the trial. Cancel anytime. We may earn a commission if you sign up.
Key Takeaways
- Prioritize titles that offer a clear detective archetype to ensure the story stays grounded.
- Check the runtime of the production because some mysteries lose their tension when stretched too thin.
- Favor period pieces if you prefer atmospheric settings over modern, tech-heavy forensic investigations.
- Look for ensemble casts since secondary characters often provide the necessary red herrings to keep you guessing.
- Verify whether the plot follows a standalone mystery or relies on ongoing arcs if you want a complete viewing experience.
| Modern Communication Interface |  |
Facebook Portal TV Smart Display | Voice activated search | Large screen integration | Simple setup process | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Classic French Whodunnit |  |
Mystery in St Tropez | Glamorous vacation setting | Humorous detective tropes | Lighthearted narrative tone | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Cult Comedy Experience |  |
Mystery Science Theater 3000 Eegah | Iconic puppet characters | Constant comedic commentary | Satirical film critique | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Atmospheric Period Drama |  |
The Suspicions Of Mr. Whicher | Rich historical setting | Authentic costume design | Intense character development | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Victorian Investigation Sequel |  |
The Suspicions Of Mr. Whicher Ties | Compelling lead performance | Strong period production values | Intricate legal plotline | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Stylish Detective Adventure |  |
Miss Fisher Crypt of Tears | Visually stunning locations | Charismatic lead character | Elegant fashion choices | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Chilling Historical True-Crime |  |
The Legend of Lizzie Borden | Compelling lead performance | Tense psychological drama | Historical intrigue | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Ultimate Manhunt Thriller |  |
The Fugitive Classic Series | High stakes manhunt | Iconic episodic structure | Relentless suspense | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Nostalgic Animated Mystery |  |
Scooby-Doo On Zombie Island | Mature thematic elements | Atmospheric animation style | Classic character ensemble | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Masterful Espionage Mystery |  |
The 39 Steps Hitchcock | Iconic directorial style | Fast-paced narrative | Influential cinematic techniques | View on Amazon | Read Review |
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
Facebook Portal TV Smart Display
You might be wondering why a hardware device tops a list of mystery shows. Think of this as the ultimate portal into your digital library, allowing you to stream Amazon Prime content with voice-controlled ease. It acts like a high-tech magnifying glass for your living room media setup.
The integration with Alexa makes finding specific mystery titles incredibly fast. You just speak your request, and the device handles the search through your connected accounts. Just remember that it requires an active internet connection and a compatible television to function properly.
- Production Type:Smart Home Hardware
- Release Era:2019
- Primary Genre:Media Streaming
- Content Format:Digital Interface
- Video Quality:High Definition
- Additional Feature:Alexa voice control integration
- Additional Feature:Smart camera framing technology
- Additional Feature:Privacy shutter for lens
-
Mystery in St Tropez
If you enjoy the frivolous charm of vintage detective comedies, this film hits the mark. It follows an eccentric inspector who travels to a glamorous location to solve a crime that is as much about social blunders as it is about clues.
The pacing feels like a brisk summer breeze. It is a lighthearted choice for those who prefer their mysteries served with a side of slapstick humor. Do not expect a grim or gritty police procedural here.
- Production Type:Feature Film
- Lead Investigator:Inspector Botta
- Release Era:2021
- Primary Genre:Comedy Mystery
- Content Format:Digital Stream
- Additional Feature:French language dialogue
- Additional Feature:Stylish costume design
- Additional Feature:Sunny coastal cinematography
-
Mystery Science Theater 3000 Eegah
This is not your typical suspense thriller. Instead, you get a hilarious commentary track layered over a bizarre B-movie about a giant living in a cave. It is perfect for viewers who want to laugh at the absurdity of low-budget filmmaking.
The chemistry between the host and the robot puppets remains the core appeal. You will find that the witty observations make even the slowest scenes entertaining. It is a niche choice, but a beloved one for fans of irony.
- Production Type:Television Series
- Lead Investigator:Joel Robinson
- Release Era:1993
- Primary Genre:Comedy Sci-Fi
- Content Format:Episodic
- Additional Feature:Puppet host segments
- Additional Feature:Original movie riffing
- Additional Feature:Low budget camp
-
The Suspicions Of Mr. Whicher
This production brings the Victorian era to life with striking detail. You follow a real-life investigator as he navigates the dark, foggy streets of London to uncover a murder. The tension builds slowly, creating a sense of dread that permeates every frame.
It works best if you enjoy meticulous period accuracy and slow-burn storytelling. The investigation feels grounded in history rather than action. Be prepared for a cerebral experience that favors dialogue over chase scenes.
- Production Type:Television Film
- Lead Investigator:Jack Whicher
- Release Era:2013
- Primary Genre:Period Mystery
- Content Format:Feature
- Additional Feature:Based on true events
- Additional Feature:Gritty urban atmosphere
- Additional Feature:Psychological character focus
-
The Suspicions Of Mr. Whicher Ties
Returning to the character of Jack Whicher, this installment deepens the emotional stakes of his professional life. You see a man trying to balance his own internal moral code with the messy realities of the criminal justice system. It feels like a natural extension of the previous chapter.
The writing remains sharp and focuses on the nuances of social class in 19th-century England. If you liked the first one, the consistency here will please you. The pacing remains deliberate and thoughtful throughout.
- Production Type:Television Film
- Lead Investigator:Jack Whicher
- Release Era:2014
- Primary Genre:Period Mystery
- Content Format:Feature
- Additional Feature:Victorian social commentary
- Additional Feature:Complex courtroom drama
- Additional Feature:Character-driven narrative
-
Miss Fisher Crypt of Tears
Phryne Fisher returns with all the glamour and intelligence that her fans expect. This adventure takes her from the jazz clubs of Melbourne to the mysterious deserts of the Middle East. It is a visual treat that never sacrifices plot for style.
The mystery elements are intertwined with high-stakes action sequences. You will appreciate the protagonist's sharp wit as she outsmarts her opponents. It works perfectly as a standalone if you are new to the series.
- Production Type:Feature Film
- Lead Investigator:Phryne Fisher
- Release Era:2020
- Primary Genre:Historical Mystery
- Content Format:Feature
- Additional Feature:International travel themes
- Additional Feature:Period-accurate aesthetic
- Additional Feature:Strong female lead
-
The Legend of Lizzie Borden
This is a tense psychological portrait of one of the most famous figures in American criminal history. You watch the story unfold through a lens that emphasizes the claustrophobia of the Borden household. It captures the mystery of the famous axe murders with lingering intensity.
The acting provides a visceral sense of the mounting pressure on the accused. You will find yourself questioning the truth right until the final moments. It is a darker pick for viewers who prefer their mysteries steeped in historical fact.
- Production Type:Television Film
- Lead Investigator:Various
- Release Era:1975
- Primary Genre:Historical True-Crime
- Content Format:Feature
- Additional Feature:Based on famous case
- Additional Feature:Moody, suspenseful pacing
- Additional Feature:Character-focused writing
-
The Fugitive Classic Series
Few shows have mastered the art of the chase like this television classic. You watch a man wrongly accused of murder as he searches for the elusive one-armed man who killed his wife. Each episode presents a new challenge in a different town.
The narrative structure creates a constant feeling of urgency that keeps you hooked for hours. Even though it dates back to the sixties, the tension feels timeless. You will likely find yourself rooting for the lead character to evade capture every single time.
- Production Type:Television Series
- Lead Investigator:Dr. Richard Kimble
- Release Era:1963
- Primary Genre:Crime Thriller
- Content Format:Episodic
- Additional Feature:Black and white aesthetic
- Additional Feature:Guest star appearances
- Additional Feature:High emotional stakes
-
Scooby-Doo On Zombie Island
Do not let the animated format fool you, as this is widely considered the darkest and best entry in the franchise. The gang reunites to investigate a genuinely spooky island filled with actual supernatural threats. It balances the humor of the series with a surprising amount of grit.
The animation style is moody and leans into a haunting atmosphere that stands out from standard Saturday morning cartoons. It is a fantastic choice for a casual but effective mystery evening. You might even find it surprisingly intense.
- Production Type:Animated Film
- Lead Investigator:Mystery Inc
- Release Era:1998
- Primary Genre:Animated Mystery
- Content Format:Feature
- Additional Feature:Supernatural horror elements
- Additional Feature:Iconic theme music
- Additional Feature:Nostalgic appeal
-
The 39 Steps Hitchcock
This film is the gold standard for the wrong-man-on-the-run subgenre. You see a man caught in a web of international espionage after a spy is murdered in his flat. It is a brilliant example of how to build suspense through simple visual storytelling.
The pace is relentless, moving from London to the Scottish Highlands with dizzying speed and precision. You should expect classic cinematic techniques that influence modern thrillers to this day. It is a short, punchy, and essential watch for any mystery fan.
- Production Type:Feature Film
- Lead Investigator:Richard Hannay
- Release Era:1935
- Primary Genre:Espionage Mystery
- Content Format:Feature
- Additional Feature:Classic suspense building
- Additional Feature:Sharp, witty dialogue
- Additional Feature:Historic film significance